Doctor Recommended

If you play with fire, you're gonna get burned -- RIAA

KaZaA sues RIAA for copyright infringement:

Sharman Networks is suing the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) for distributing replicas of its P2P file sharing software.

Sharman says the RIAA has distributed versions of KaZaA Lite with warning messages to potential infringers, which it deems "monopolistic and conspiratorial" behavior. In July a Judge nixed an attempt by Sharman Networks to stop the distribution of RIAA-flavored KaZaA software using Antitrust legislation. That failed, but this time it's trying again.

This latest twist highlights some of the RIAA's stranger behavior. The copyright-cartel has been playing fast and loose with other people's copyrights: while claiming that it is upholding the law, it has proved only too happy to break it. And while claiming to uphold the integrity of the music it distributes, it has pioneered the art of poisoning works of art with clicks and hisses.

But the RIAA hasn't escaped Antitrust scrutiny just yet: last month it was sued by the Webcaster Alliance. An unguarded comment by an RIAA attorney expressed the lobby's groups satisfaction at seeing 25,000 smaller webcasters perish, if AOL could stream 200 channels.

Careless talk. ®

Is this a case of pot calling the kettle black? Not really. If the RIAA is going to try to use the State to bolster it's claims, it should also expect retaliation of the same order (fighting fire with fire...).

Though this irony reminds me of Sharman using the DMCA to squelch "rogue" listings on Google.

Posted by Tim at September 24, 2003 04:15 PM | TrackBack